Behind a Shield: Seeing My Father for Who He Was

Matthew Vire • June 15, 2025

A Father's Day Reflection

As children, we give our fathers and mothers special status. For better or worse, they hold power over us. We’re vulnerable to and with them. We’re shaped by them, whether we conform to their expectations or actively diverge from them. Even if they’re been absent, they have an impact.


I didn’t have a close relationship with my father. We saw the world very differently. But in my younger years I enjoyed spending time with him. I remember the smell of his workshop, our garage: the scents of motor oil, dirt, dampness, and the distinct odor of metal. And the images of it: those banged-up trash cans to my right as I walked in, next to the big overhead door, open in warm weather, closed in cold; half of the two-car bay empty but for tools and stuff lying on the cement floor, the other half occupied by an old truck I’m sure he tinkered on for years, a truck I don't think I ever saw run. The room was lit by fluorescents and natural light filtered through dusty windows onto cracked pegboard walls holding tools over a workbench with its jars and coffee cans of unsorted screws, nails, and bolts, and my father’s breakfast beer, fizzing by the radio speaker. It was a bit like Sanford and Son, but without the catchy theme music.


One day in that garage, he told me about his work in a tone that made clear he had no love for it. “I crawl into a hole and stare a light all day. Then I come home.” He was a welder. And on weekends, he found ways to put his main vocational skill to use at home. He had a welding machine at home and would use it to patch up old cars and I’m not sure what else. The first time I saw him welding, he warned me, “Don’t look at the light—you’ll go blind.” He reached into a tool box. “You have to look through this,” he said, and gave me a piece of glass like the one in his face shield, so black I could see nothing through it at all. But when he started working again, I saw the glow, still intense but not painful, and a shower of sparks. This was the light he focused on for hours on end, mending ships and submarines at a job he disliked to support his family. All this time staring at a bright light surrounded by the absolute darkness.


I think Sunday mornings were one of my father’s favorite times. I would wake up in the room I shared with my older brother to the sound of hateful, self-righteous, angry sermons. Dad favored Jerry Falwell, Jimmy Swaggart, and Vernon McGee, and their voices echoed down the hall from the kitchen into my room. My father turned the volume of the radio or TV up high so he could hear it wherever he went in the house. Many Sunday mornings he wasn’t even in the house when I woke up, but he had the sermon on so he could hear it if he stepped inside from the garage where a second radio or TV blared the same broadcast. I really hated that sound, but somehow it comforted him. 


He had good reason to wear that shield when he was working, so he wouldn’t be blinded or burned. It offered real protection. And the sermons he studied also shielded him, severely restricting his view of the world. Both at work and at home, he saw world through a very dark lens.


Fatherhood is complicated. Labels and archetypes add layers and nuances of expectation that few of us can live up to fully. I was well into my thirties when I first understood—really understood—that my father was just a person. He judged himself harshly. He loved his children fiercely. He worked hard to support his family. And he tried to live up to the expectations he believed the world had of him. Shaped by his own upbringing—by parents who were themselves just people; by his limitations, real and perceived; and by his faith, rooted in 'fear of God'—he did the best he could.

By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes October 28, 2025
All Saint's Day
By Rev. Richard Brendan October 21, 2025
Practicing Joy
October 15, 2025
On a crisp October morning, something unexpected happened at a community breakfast in Fishers, Indiana: Christmas came early. But this wasn't about jumping the gun on holiday decorating or premature caroling. Instead, it was about something much more meaningful: using the story of Christmas to build understanding across faith traditions. A Gathering of Neighbors The Niagara Foundation, a national organization dedicated to fostering relationships between people of different cultures and faiths, hosts quarterly community breakfasts through its central Indiana chapter, operated by the Turkish Muslim community. These gatherings bring together anyone who shares a simple but powerful desire to break down barriers and build bridges in our increasingly diverse world. At their community center in Fishers, the Foundation regularly invites speakers from various faith traditions to share perspectives with the group. On October 11, 2025, it was Betty Brandt's turn. As Program Director at the Garden Community Church, Betty chose to explore the topic of Christmas, familiar to most yet full of surprising history. The History Behind the Holiday Betty's presentation explored how Christmas as we know it came to be. She explained that December 25 wasn't celebrated as Jesus' birthday until 330 AD, when Pope Julius decreed it "The Feast of the Nativity." This date wasn't chosen randomly. Appropriating the pagan holiday allowed early Christians to continue celebrating the pagan winter solstice, the return of the sun, with its lights, candles, and festivities, while assigning new Christian meaning to these traditions. From there, Betty traced the evolution of beloved Christmas traditions including the transformation of Saint Nicholas into Santa Claus, the development of Christmas carols, the adoption of evergreen trees as symbols of eternal life, and the creation of live nativity scenes. Each tradition, she showed, carried layers of cultural adaptation and meaning. A Story That Captures Everything Betty concluded with a true story from December 24, 1944, during the brutal Battle of the Bulge in World War II. As a fierce snowstorm raged, three American soldiers and three German soldiers took refuge in the home of a Belgian woman and her son. In that small house, on Christmas Eve, these young men put down their weapons. Together, they accepted the hospitality offered to them, shared a meal, and for one night, chose humanity over hatred. This story captured the essence of what brought people to that October breakfast. Just as those soldiers had done decades earlier, those present desired to put aside differences, enjoy a wonderful meal together, and build bridges across the divides that too often separate us. Looking Ahead The next Niagara Foundation community breakfast will take place in 2026 and will feature a panel discussion on fasting practices across different faith traditions. While no date has been set yet, the event promises another opportunity to learn, connect, and discover the common threads that run through our diverse beliefs. Whereas our world often emphasizes what divides us, gatherings like these remind us that our shared humanity is stronger than our differences. Sometimes it takes a story about Christmas—told in October, in a Muslim community center, to a room full of neighbors—to help us remember that truth. To learn more about the Niagara Foundation and upcoming community breakfast events, visit their website .
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes October 14, 2025
What Does it Mean to Be a Good Neighbor?
By Betty Brandt October 13, 2025
Posters with Purpose: Preparing for the No Kings Rally
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes October 6, 2025
Honoring Indigenous Peoples
By Betty Brandt October 1, 2025
MirrorIndy fills the local news gap with citizen-powered reporting. See how Documenters create public records and hold officials accountable.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes September 30, 2025
World Communion Sunday 2025
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes September 24, 2025
Dear Friends, Please read these two important announcements: First: We’re excited to share that The Garden has now officially moved into our new home at 7171 North Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46240. This is a joyful new chapter for our community, and we’re so grateful for the ways you’ve helped us grow into it. If you give to The Garden through your bank, IRA, or BillPay service, please take a moment to update our new address with your financial institution so your gifts continue to reach us smoothly. Second: We hope you will be with us for our Annual All‑Church Meeting on Sunday, October 5, immediately following the 9 a.m. service at the church. As a United Methodist congregation, this is one of those “official business” gatherings we hold each year. It’s short and simple—we’ll share financial updates, answer questions, and take care of the necessary business of being a church family. Even in our untraditional way of doing things, this meeting is a reminder that we’re in this together—tending The Garden with love, transparency, and care. With gratitude and joy, Carolyn and The Garden Leadership Team P.S. Please reply to this email if you have any questions we can answer!
September 24, 2025
Your Voice Matters