Held by Mystery

David Bolander • August 22, 2025

Spirituality as Secure Attachment in Spiritually Diverse Communities

In a world that often feels fragmented and fast-moving, many of us long for a place to land—a presence that says, “You are safe. You are seen.” For some, that presence is God. For others, it’s Spirit, Love, the Universe, or simply the sacred pulse of life itself. In spiritually diverse communities—where the divine is explored through tradition, experience, scripture, and mystery—this longing is not dismissed. It’s honored.


Attachment Theory and the Sacred


Attachment theory, rooted in the work of John Bowlby, teaches that our earliest relationships shape how we connect, trust, and feel safe. When those early bonds are nurturing, we internalize a sense of worth and security. When they’re fractured, we may carry wounds that echo through adulthood.

But healing is possible—and for many, it begins in the spiritual realm.


Researchers like Pehr Granqvist and Lee Kirkpatrick have explored how people form attachment relationships with the divine. Whether through prayer, meditation, music, or ritual, spiritual connection can offer:


  • A safe haven in times of emotional distress
  • A secure base from which to explore life’s complexity
  • A mirror that reflects back our inherent worth


Michael John Cusick’s Sacred Attachment beautifully explores this dynamic, offering a trauma-informed lens on how divine love can become a healing force in our lives.


The Divine as a Loving Presence


In communities that honor varied spiritual paths, the divine is not confined to a single image or doctrine. It may be experienced as:


  • The Christ who walks with the marginalized
  • The Spirit that dances in creativity and justice
  • The Mystery that holds all things together
  • The Love that transcends binaries and borders


This openness allows people to form spiritual attachments that feel authentic, healing, and deeply personal.


Spiritual Attachment Styles


Just as we have human attachment styles, we also carry spiritual ones. These influence how we relate to the sacred:


  • Secure attachment style expresses in faith as trust in divine presence and grace
  • Anxious style expresses in faith as fear of abandonment
  • Avoidant style expresses in faith as skepticism or detachment from spiritual practices
  • Disorganized style expresses in faith as conflicted or traumatic spiritual history

 

Spiritually diverse communities often create space for all of these—welcoming the doubter, the seeker, the wounded, and the mystic alike.


Healing Through Sacred Connection


In a church where music ranges from Taizé chants to indie folk, where sermons quote both scripture and poetry, and where the divine is spoken of with reverence and curiosity, healing happens. People begin to feel held—not just by community, but by something deeper.


Spiritual practices like contemplative prayer, embodied worship, and shared silence can rewire our nervous systems toward trust. Over time, the divine becomes not just an idea, but a felt presence—a secure attachment figure that walks with us through joy, grief, and transformation.


If this reflection resonates, consider sitting with these questions—not to arrive at answers, but to deepen your awareness of how you relate to the sacred:

  • What does “being held” by the divine mean to you—and when have you felt it most clearly? Explore moments of spiritual safety, even if they were fleeting.
  • How do your early relationships shape the way you seek or resist spiritual connection today? Notice any echoes between attachment and faith.
  • What spiritual practices help you feel seen, soothed, or grounded? Consider what brings you closer to a felt sense of presence.
  • Is there a part of your spiritual story that feels tender, conflicted, or unfinished? Let this be a space to honor complexity without judgment.



References


Cusick, M. J. (2025). Sacred Attachment: Escaping Spiritual Exhaustion and Trusting in Divine Love. IVP Formatio. InterVarsity Press.


Cherniak, A. D., Mikulincer, M., Shaver, P. R., & Granqvist, P. (2021). Attachment theory and religion. Current Opinion in Psychology, 40, 126–130. APA PsycNet.


Freund, A., Fuchshuber, J., Silani, G., & Unterrainer, H. F. (2024). The relationship between attachment, primary emotions and positive/negative spirituality: a path analysis. Frontiers in Public Health. Frontiers Journal.


Hiebler-Ragger, M., et al. (2016). Facets of Spirituality Diminish the Positive Relationship between Insecure Attachment and Mood Pathology in Young Adults. PLOS ONE. PLOS Journal.



David Bolander, M.Div., M.A., LMHCA (he/him), is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate offering inclusive, attachment-based therapy for adults navigating anxiety, depression, identity exploration, and relational trauma. His approach is warm, emotionally attuned, and grounded in deep respect for each person’s story. As a gay therapist, David is passionate about supporting the LGBTQ+ community and creating spaces of authenticity, belonging, and emotional safety. Drawing from Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), psychodynamic theory, and contemplative spirituality, David helps clients explore emotional wounds, trace attachment patterns, and reconnect with their worth. His work is shaped by two decades of leadership in spiritual and community settings, and by a belief that healing is relational, existential, and often sacred. David offers individual and group counseling both in person and online. His professional listings are available on Open Path, Therapy Den, and Psychology Today.

July 6, 2026
Explore the U.S. Constitution's relevance today. Join us for insights on its principles & impact on society.
June 29, 2026
We often hear the phrase, "Make sure you read the fine print," as we navigate the complexities of daily life. Whether it's the Constitution, the Bible, or even the manual for our computers, there's a wealth of fine print that tends to be skimmed over, misinterpreted, or entirely overlooked. Yet these details often hold the key to understanding the bigger picture and guiding us through life's challenges. This week, we're excited to launch a three-week series titled "The Fine Print." Over the next few Sundays, we'll take a closer look at some of the most important documents that shape our lives and values. Week 1: We'll explore The Declaration of Independence—a powerful statement of freedom and the rights of individuals that still resonates today. Week 2: Our focus shifts to The Constitution, examining its vital principles and how they continue to influence our society. Week 3: We'll conclude with a deep dive into The Bible, uncovering the profound truths and teachings that guide our faith and actions. Each message will stand on its own, so if you happen to miss one, rest assured you can still enjoy and engage with the others — though we'd love to have you for the whole series. Join us this Sunday for The Fine Print—a journey that promises to deepen our understanding and appreciation of these foundational texts. Together, we'll discover how the details within these documents can illuminate our paths and enrich our lives. You won't want to miss it!
June 23, 2026
We have often heard the words, "It is more blessed to give than to receive." The phrase is so well-known that many people don't even realize it is found in the Bible (Acts 20:35). So, is it just a cliché, or does God truly do something in the heart of a giving person—something that blesses both them and the world in which they live? Research shows that this is no mere platitude. Our brains respond to generosity by triggering a significant positive feedback loop when we practice, receive, or even simply witness giving in action. In a 2008 study, researchers found that people who spent money on others reported a notably higher uptick in happiness than those who spent it on themselves. Interestingly, this difference had nothing to do with how much they spent, but rather the direction of their spending. Giving really does benefit everyone—the giver, the receiver, and the witness—and the effect ripples outward. And it’s not just about monetary gifts, but also gifts of kindness and service. What we do, and how we give, truly matters. Join us Sunday as we explore how God turns giving into the blessing of receiving.
By Lea Ann Koekenberg June 22, 2026
Day 2 of Adventures with Moses
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes June 16, 2026
This Sunday, we celebrate Father's Day—a special occasion to honor the remarkable men who have shaped our life journeys: biological fathers, teachers, mentors, coaches, and friends. Each of us carries unique experiences that contribute to who we are, and it's important to recognize that no two stories are alike. Take comfort in knowing that there is no such thing as one perfect family. Even Jesus grew up in an unconventional household, with both Joseph and God as His Father. Yes, Jesus had two dads!  Join us this Sunday for a service filled with heartfelt stories, laughter, and powerful insights. We'll reflect on the diverse expressions of fatherhood and celebrate all the father figures in our lives—whether traditional or not. This is a wonderful opportunity to deepen your relationship with God and embrace a love that transcends all family structures. Come ready to be inspired and uplifted—bring your friends and family, and let's celebrate together. We can't wait to see you!
By LeaAnn Koekenberg June 15, 2026
Day 1 of Adventures with Moses God is our protector
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes June 10, 2026
This Saturday, Indianapolis comes alive as we celebrate Pride 2026 with a vibrant parade, a lively festival, and a powerful celebration of resilience, activism, and community building. It’s a time to honor our journey, reflecting on the progress we’ve made while acknowledging the work that still lies ahead in achieving true equality and acceptance for all members of the LGBTQ+ community—both in Indiana and across the nation. Join us this Sunday as we pause to reflect on our journey, the milestones we've reached and the miles we still must travel toward inclusivity and love. Together, we will share in the sacred mission of creating spaces where every one of God’s children feels valued and embraced as part of our family of faith. Let’s gather to celebrate the beauty of diversity, to uplift one another, and to commit ourselves to a future where love knows no bounds. This is not just a celebration; it’s a call to action for all of us to be the welcoming arms of love at The Garden. Don’t miss this opportunity to be inspired, uplifted, and empowered as we stand together in pride and faith!
May 29, 2026
Woodstock was more than a festival. It was a moment when people chose peace over violence, community over division, and love over fear. Those values still speak to our culture today--calling us to show up, stand together, and create a world that works for ALL. Join us Sunday, June 7 for Music Sunday at The Garden when the rock band Opening Day will take over our service. Opening Day is a psychedelic band from Indianapolis led by songwriter and guitarist Casper Willow. Blending a vast palette of experimental, progressive, and art/folk influences, the band crafts immersive live experiences designed to offer audiences a moment to pause, feel, and reconnect. This mini concert will feature songs by Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young; Santana; Led Zeppelin; The Grateful Dead; The Who; Janis Joplin; and Joan Baez among others. See you there!
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes May 26, 2026
What does true community look like? How can we cultivate a closer, stronger, more loving one where we all thrive, belong, and prosper? Where isolation and fear divide us, the church can be a beacon of unity and love. Community is more than a gathering of people; it is a chosen interconnectedness, a tapestry woven together by the divine within us. While we may find ourselves part of a community by circumstance, we can also join and co-create them with intention. This Sunday, we'll reimagine the meaning of community, why it matters, and how we can lovingly, compassionately, and joyfully cultivate it in our lives. Join us for "The Art of Community."
By Mike Ransom May 19, 2026
Hunger is Rising — and God Calls Us to Respond