Sacred Journeys: Psychedelics and the Search for Meaning

Betty Brandt • August 8, 2025

Spirituality and Psychedelics

I spent several decades of my adult life as a practicing Marriage & Family Therapist. In all those years, I encountered a handful of people whose depressive symptoms had such a hold on them, they were immobilized. It seemed that no treatments were available to help them enjoy life again.


Today, the medical use of psychedelics is adding a powerful option. Much research is being done in this field, with quite astounding results. There are a growing number of places in Indianapolis where people suffering from depression can take psychedelics in the presence of trained therapeutic practitioners.


Now, research is expanding into the field of spirituality and psychedelics. The best-known study is a 2016 collaboration between Johns Hopkins and NYU Schools of Medicine, involving 22 religious leaders—Episcopalian, Presbyterian, Methodist, Lutheran, United Church of Christ, Congregational, Baptist, Eastern Orthodox, Pentecostal, Reformed Church in America, Roman Catholic, Unitarian Universalist, Orthodox Jew, Reconstructionist Jew, Renewal Jew, Sunni Muslim, and Zen Buddhist.


The results, which were delayed for almost a decade, are now available. They reveal that 96% of the participants retroactively rated their psilocybin experience among the top five most spiritually significant, profoundly sacred, psychologically insightful, and meaningful experiences of their lives.


Some came to see all religions as part of one truth, while many felt more grounded in their personal traditions. Some attributed their psychedelic experiences entirely to God, while others credited chemical changes in their brains. They reported positive changes in their effectiveness as religious leaders, as well as in their non-religious attitudes, moods, and behaviors.


Are we on the cusp of a dramatic change in the acceptance of psychedelics beyond medical uses?


The American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978 safeguards the use, possession, and transportation of peyote by Indigenous people for bona fide traditional ceremonial purposes. Now, a non-Indigenous group in Utah has sued—and won—their case.


On August 4, 2025, District Judge Jill Parrish of the U.S. District Court of Utah ruled in favor of a religious group called Singularism, which had sued for the right to use psychedelic mushrooms in their worship services as a conduit to profound spiritual experiences. Judge Parrish sided with the group.


Just two days later, on August 6, 2025, Rabbi Jay Michaelson spoke at a Spirit and Place event in Indianapolis. Rabbi Michaelson is a field scholar at the Emory Center for Psychedelics and Spirituality and a fellow at Harvard Law School’s Project on Psychedelic Use, Law, and Spiritual Experience (PULSE).


In March 2025, he co-organized the first-ever conference on the legal recognition of religious psychedelic use in Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities. His colleague, Gary Laderman—a religion scholar at Emory University—has a book titled Sacred Drugs: How Psychoactive Substances Mix with Religious Life, coming out in September 2025. These two men are leaders in this emerging field of spirituality and psychedelics.


I have lots of questions. Maybe you do too.


Are we approaching a time when psychedelics will be welcomed into the spiritual practices of American faith traditions? If so, how long until that door opens?


Would I be willing to take part in a religious ceremony using psychedelics? Would you?


How would such an experience transform my spiritual life?


Could clergy take part in a psychedelic experience as part of their seminary training?


Do seminaries need to train religious leaders to provide care and guidance to those in their congregations who want to process their psychedelic experiences?


A whole new opportunity for spiritual growth is opening before us. Are we ready?

By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes December 29, 2025
Today, with GPS at our fingertips, most of us rarely unfold a map—let alone look up to the stars. We navigate by screens that pull our attention downward, keeping our focus just a few inches from our faces. This Sunday, we’ll take a step back in time to when travelers—like the Magi—lifted their eyes to the night sky for direction and inspiration. As we enter the season of Epiphany, we’ll explore what it means to look up again, to notice the light around us, and to follow the kinds of “stars” that guide us toward meaning, connection, and the places that feel most sacred in our lives. Join us Sunday for “Finding Our Way.”
A hand writes in a notebook with a pencil. A window in the background shows an orange sunset.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes December 22, 2025
A New Page, A New Dawn
December 22, 2025
This Christmas Eve, First Congregational Church of Indy and The Garden come together to celebrate the joy and wonder of Jesus’ birth in this shared service. We are delighted to join voices and hearts for this special evening. The service will weave together gifts of both congregations—music, prayer, readings, and storytelling—in a spirit of unity and welcome. Whether you are part of FCIndy or The Garden, or simply seeking a place to experience the wonder of Christmas, we welcome you as we celebrate the light that shines in the darkness and the hope that brings us together.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes December 15, 2025
This Sunday is the Winter Solstice, the longest night of the year. On this Longest Night, we pause to remember that God is with us through it all. From moments of awe and beauty to times of sickness and grief, we are never alone. This season brings with it all kinds of feelings. Sometimes it helps to acknowledge that the twinkling lights and merry songs of Christmas can also deepen the shadows for those coping with grief, pain, fear, or loss. It is not always easy to hear “Have a Holly Jolly Christmas!” and other cheerful tunes when we may be personally struggling. On Sunday, we will conclude our Advent journey with the theme “Do You Feel What I Feel?” Together, we’ll recognize that we each come to this season with different emotions and experiences. Let’s pause and explore how we can support and care for one another, knowing that we all arrive here from different places and with different stories. Join us for “Do You Feel What I Feel?”
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes December 9, 2025
Join us this Advent season for a thought-provoking sermon titled "Do You See Who I See?" as we explore the profound theme of immigration through the lens of faith. Together, we'll revisit the story of Mary and Joseph's journey to Bethlehem, noting parallels to the experiences of immigrants today. We will consider the importance of seeing beyond borders and recognizing the dignity and humanity in every individual. Prepare to open your hearts and minds as we embrace the spirit of compassion and understanding this Advent, celebrating the sacred diversity of God's creation. In reflecting on these timeless truths, we will be challenged to live out our faith in ways that welcome the stranger and extend hospitality to all. May this gathering remind us that the Advent story is not only about waiting, but also about acting with courage and love in our communities. Don't miss this opportunity to deepen our faith and engage with the world around us.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes December 1, 2025
Listening for God’s song in the season
By Rev. Richard Brendan November 26, 2025
Light in Unexpected Places
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes November 18, 2025
In this Sunday’s service, we’ll reflect together on how our journey as a church--full of movement, growth, and change—-mirrors God’s ongoing work in each of our lives. Through three short messages, we will celebrate the many ways that nurturing our spiritual community and sharing God’s blessings can feed not only our own souls but also the hearts of those around us. As we bring this year’s stewardship campaign to a close, we invite you to consider how your gifts of time, talent, and resources help The Garden continue to flourish. Stewardship is not only about sustaining our church; it is about embodying God’s love in action—-on the go, in our homes, workplaces, and neighborhoods. Together we create a community where generosity and compassion ripple outward, touching lives far beyond our walls. Let’s take this opportunity to reflect on how we can keep growing, contributing, and carrying God’s love into the world. We look forward to celebrating our shared mission and the joy and lasting power of giving with you this Sunday at The Garden.
By Joleen House November 17, 2025
How hugs, service, and fellowship shaped one Gardener’s spiritual journey
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes November 11, 2025
Have you ever experienced a hunger so profound that nothing seems to satisfy it? You might turn to junk food, healthy snacks, or every culinary delight in between, and still feel a gnawing emptiness. This discontent often signals something deeper, a spiritual hunger or longing that the world’s offerings cannot fulfill. In our quest for satisfaction, we frequently look to satiate our physical needs, while it’s our spirit that craves nourishment. This Sunday, we will consider what we genuinely hunger and thirst for. Together, we’ll explore the myriad ways we attempt to fill those voids, often to find ourselves still dissatisfied and yearning for more. Imagine what it would be like to genuinely feed your hungry heart, to find true fulfillment in spiritual nourishment. We’ll share in the profound experience of intimate communion with the Divine, discovering how to look beyond our material lives for the spiritual satisfaction that transcends our earthly desires. Join us this Sunday for “Feeding the Hungry Heart.” Together, we will uncover the depths of our cravings and learn how to find lasting peace and fulfillment through a deeper relationship with God. Let’s embark on this journey of discovery and nourishment, and fill our hearts with the sustenance they truly seek.