Are You a "Recovering Christian"? You're Not Alone.

Matthew Vire • March 7, 2022

I grew up Catholic, and I remember how deeply devout I was as a child. Then something happened. The love and comfort I felt in the belief that I was inseparably connected to God turned into something else: fear, shame, and self-loathing. I had come to recognize that I could never be the person the church told me I must be.

I was taught that I would be damned to eternal punishment for something over which I had no control. I was told that I should have control, that actually I did, and that my inability to change was a personal and willful failure, a rejection of God’s will. No amount of prayer and willing myself to be straight made a difference. I hated myself for it, and I was told that this, too, was a sin. I despaired for years. I still haven’t shaken that feeling completely.

Even before I knew I was gay, I felt a growing sense of unease around the church. There was much love in evidence. However, the love was inherently conditional on obedience to rules from the Bible, an ancient and self-contradicting text revered by my elders as the literal word of God, its stories taught as historical fact. I wanted to believe. I could not. And at the same time, I could not stop believing.

Then there were the preachers I heard regularly. My father was not Catholic, but he identified as a “God-fearing” man. He tuned the radio to ranting, angry-sounding sermons of men like Vernon McGee, Jimmy Swaggart, and Jerry Fallwell. They all told me I was garbage, without hope of redemption unless I could resist or expunge my homosexuality. I heard them so often that to this day, I cringe viscerally at the sound of evangelical preaching—even the non-judgmental, inclusive kind.

That I am active with The Garden attests to its genuine, loving inclusivity. I feel accepted, yes; welcomed, absolutely; valued, without question. I trust the leadership, integrity, and intent of The Garden. But I don’t feel at home. The wound is too deep.

Do you relate to any of this? Do my thoughts resonate with you? Do they make you feel like defending the church? To what degree do you feel at home when you find yourself in a faith community, whether weekly by choice or occasionally at a funeral or wedding?

We’re talking about the church — and a lot more* — Monday evenings through March 28 in The Generation Project: Call Me By My Name. This group is decidedly not about evangelism. You’re encouraged to come in person,
but you can join us on Zoom, too. Come share your story. Ask questions and share your feelings in a supportive forum. We do not seek to convert you. But we would love to hear you.

*Topics include but may not be limited to pronoun preferences, gender roles and identity, church hurt, and the role a faith community might serve for those who have been (or continue to feel) not-at-home in church.



By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • November 18, 2026
Thanksgiving
November 14, 2026
Watch Quaker pastor and author Philip Gulley’s evening at The Garden on hope, faith, community, and the leaders we need, recorded November 13, 2026.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • November 10, 2026
Ever wished life had a rewind button? We’ve all made wrong turns, run from what we knew was right, or felt like we completely blew our shot. This Sunday, we welcome 2nd Chance Indiana, which helps people coming home from prison find work through job training, mentoring, and rides to and from their jobs. It’s a program built around the do-over: going back and trying again. As our fourth-quarter Big Give recipient, they’ll receive The Garden’s $2,000 donation during the service. We’ll also revisit the story of Jonah, the prophet who ran the other way and ended up in the belly of a great fish. Even then, the story says, “the word of the Lord came to Jonah a second time.” Even when we give up or run away, God never gives up on us. Grace always awaits your next chapter.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • November 3, 2026
Have you ever used a stair climber at the gym? It’s designed so that you’re climbing the same few steps over and over and over again. You put in an incredible amount of work, sweat, and effort, but you never actually go anywhere. Does life sometimes feel that way? Like you’re taking the same few steps over and over? Are there times when you feel like you’re on a spiritual stair climber? Life wasn’t designed to work that way. As people of faith, we are called to order our steps so that our future is guided not by our own limited stride, but by a divine path and perspective. This Sunday’s message, “Stepping Up,” considers what it takes to break out of the loop, step it up, and live each day to its absolute fullest through spiritual reflection, positioning, and prospering. As Proverbs 16:9 reminds us, “The heart of man plans his way, but the Lord establishes his steps.” Don’t just drift through your week. Start positioning yourself for what God wants to do next. Bring a notebook, bring a friend, and let’s get ready to step up together!
LeaAnn Koekenberg
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • October 29, 2026
Pastor Carolyn shares news of Lea Ann’s new role and invites you to celebrate her four years of loving and teaching our children on Sunday, November 8.
By Helen Payne • October 28, 2026
Each year at The Garden, we collect donated laundry baskets filled with specific household items to be given to families in need. These items cannot be purchased with SNAP funds, and for those living in poverty it can be difficult to afford these essentials. If you would like to donate, you can either make a monetary contribution and we will shop, or you can purchase and fill a basket and bring it to The Garden by Sunday, November 29. The following items are requested for each donation: 1 Large, Quality Laundry Basket 1 Bar of Soap 4 Toothbrushes 1 Large or 2 Smaller (4 or 5 oz) Toothpaste 1 Large (42-50 oz) Laundry Detergent 1 Large (15-16 oz) Dish Soap 1 Bottle (8 oz) Liquid Hand Soap 1 Roll Paper Towels 4-6 Rolls of Toilet Paper 1 Box of Facial Tissue 1 Large (16 oz) Bottle of Shampoo 1 Bottle (18 oz) of All-Purpose Cleaner We will also gratefully accept cash donations and volunteers to shop with.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • October 28, 2026
All Saints Day
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes • October 19, 2026
 In World War II, a “Dear John” letter was synonymous with breaking up. When The Garden was founded some 30 years ago, we sent our own “Dear John” letter to the United Methodist Church. We felt the path the traditional church had taken was too narrow, and The Garden wanted to champion “many paths and one purpose.” However, about 10 years ago, we realized we needed to co-parent this message of hope and love, so we reluctantly joined the Conference as a UMC congregation. This year, I’ve had the opportunity to get reacquainted with our Methodist roots and John Wesley himself. For me, it has felt like going to a class reunion and falling back in love with a high school sweetheart—realizing that even though we took different paths, we still have so much in common, and well, maybe it's time to get back together? This Sunday, we will look at how The Garden has lived into the very core message that John Wesley preached. We will consider how being part of the UMC connection can help us transform the world with God's love, and how The Garden can help the UMC see that there are truly many loving paths. Join us this Sunday for “Dear John.”
By Jerry Zehr • October 13, 2026
What makes some people extraordinarily generous, even when they have so little to give, while others who have so much find it difficult to share? In his letter to the Corinthians, Paul describes the Macedonian churches, whose poverty and hardships did not diminish their generosity. Instead, their joy overflowed into giving. Through personal stories and encounters with unexpected generosity, we'll explore what happens when grace becomes more than something we receive. It becomes something we share. Grace isn't something we hold on to. It's something we allow to flow through us. As The Garden reflects on its future, we have an opportunity to ask a deeper question: What kind of community do we want to create together? What would it look like to become a community where love, compassion, acceptance, and generosity overflow into the lives of others? Perhaps the greatest gift we have to offer isn't what we possess, but who we are and how we choose to share ourselves with the world. When grace overflows, generosity isn't something we have to do. It's something we get to do.
By Rev. Richard Brendan • October 8, 2026
Indigenous Peoples Day invites us to pause and remember that we live on land with a story much older than our own. It is a day to listen to the voices, wisdom, stories, and resilience of Indigenous peoples and to acknowledge the painful history that is also a part of this land’s story. It calls us to move beyond simply remembering and to ask: “How might we live with greater humility, gratitude, and respect for the people and the Earth who have been here long before us?”