What is Discernment?

Matthew Vire • January 27, 2023

 

Discerning Minds Want to Know

Generally, "discernment" refers to one's ability to make sound judgments. But according to Oxford Languages Dictionary discernment can, in Christian contexts, emphasize "perception in the absence of judgment with a view to obtaining spiritual guidance and understanding" (emphasis mine). As we try to reconcile these two contradictory meanings of the same word, we might ponder the differences between perception and discernment, how one serves the other, and the limitations of both.

We know very well -- but often forget or choose to deny -- that our perceptions are limited and often flawed. Still, we make judgments based on those perceptions. Perhaps the two disparate meanings serve to highlight the importance of careful, conscious, evaluation of what we see (or think we see), what is important, and how we respond to life as it unfolds.

So, is discernment about judgment or perception? Well, why not both? Maybe discernment means recognizing the importance of making judgments with humility and care, knowing that we base them on our own perceptions.

In this service, Carolyn concludes our Star Words series with some reflections on her star word, Discernment.

By Matthew Vire July 22, 2025
Call for Photo Submissions
July 21, 2025
Psalms and the Healing Arc of Our Stories
By Matthew Vire July 21, 2025
Together to Gather
July 21, 2025
This Sunday, The Garden welcomes visionary composer and musician Ryan Lott, founder of the genre-defying band Son Lux. Known for his emotionally rich soundscapes and collaborations with artists like Mitski, David Byrne, and Paul Simon, Lott has scored major films including the recent Marvel blockbuster, Thunderbolts* , and the acclaimed Everything Everywhere All at Once , earning Academy Award and BAFTA nominations. In conversation with Richard Brendan, Ryan will share insights into his creative journey as we explore the transformative power of imagination.  We hope to see you at our temporary venue—740 E 86th Street, Indianapolis—at 9 a.m. for “Celebrating the Creative Spirit.” Join us for a morning of inspiration, music, and meaningful conversation.
July 21, 2025
In "Together to Gather" after our first service at our temporary new venue, we enjoyed a look back to The Garden's beginning and its evolution over the past 30 years. Joleen House, who has been with The Garden since day one, shared some memories and a clip of Rev. Linda McCoy. In the clip, Linda spoke of her inspiration to create The Garden. A slide show of photos through the years followed, with discussion. Please note that we recorded this on the spur of the moment by request and a mobile phone -- while the band was doing its necessary break-down and load-out of our equipment from the space. Because of this, the audio may be difficult to hear at times. 
a man kindly picks up a newspaper from the ground
By Betty Brandt July 21, 2025
A heartfelt tribute to everyday heroes in one neighborhood—retirees Morrie and Sam—whose quiet acts of kindness nourish community spirit and connection.
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes July 14, 2025
Together, Let's See What's Next
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes July 8, 2025
Welcome, IYG, our next Big Give Recipient!
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes June 30, 2025
Freedom and Responsibility
By Rev. Dr. Carolyn Scanlan-Holmes June 24, 2025
Messages from the Mountaintop